Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 10, 2023 at 11:45 in reply to: West Asia and “Al-Aqsa Flood” Battle Thread, 09 Oct 2023 #19361
Sudhi
ParticipantIndeed, they may have planned,
and others have also planned,
but who is “the best of planners”?October 10, 2023 at 11:10 in reply to: West Asia and “Al-Aqsa Flood” Battle Thread, 09 Oct 2023 #19358Sudhi
ParticipantWhat oddities accompany the Hamas attack on Israel: analysis of the Military Chronicle
Each circumstance is important both individually and in a complex of issues related to the Israeli security system.
Oddity No. 1 – Israel did not know about the preparations for the attack.
Gaza is a narrow piece of land with an area of 365 square meters. km. It was believed that it was bugged and monitored far and wide by the Israeli army and intelligence services, but during the attack it turned out that this was not the case. Presumably, Hamas developed a system for coordination and communication that excluded electronic contacts, and somehow the Palestinians managed to hide everything from Israeli intelligence.Oddity No. 2 – Israel was unable to prevent the attack.
Shortly before the attack on checkpoints and major cities on October 7, Hamas organizedly deployed MLRS, ground forces, paragliders and other equipment to positions. The preparations and first steps went unnoticed, and the preemptive strike was not launched.Oddity No. 3 – the alarm system at the border did not work.
The electronic systems at the border, which Israel had invested billions of dollars in building and equipping, were rendered useless. Numerous cameras and sensors also did not help detect and stop the Palestinian attack, as well as combat patrols, which for some reason simply were not nearby. Palestinian drones were able to easily hit automatic machine guns and sensor towers, and Hamas assault teams calmly blew up the fence and crossed the border. Nobody is trying to attack them. Due to the failure of the alarm, hundreds of IDF soldiers were killed in the camps, in the barracks, and while sleeping.Oddity #4: Hamas tactics.
Contrary to popular belief, the Palestinians did not bypass IDF fortifications and bases. They took it aggressivelystormed both checkpoints and bases where armored vehicles were located. At the same time, Hamas stopped using tanks – apparently due to the low qualifications of the attackers or lack of need. It is still unclear where the sentries, security guards on duty and cover forces were located at that time.Oddity No. 5 – the readiness of military equipment.
The Israeli Merkava Mk.4 tank, destroyed by a copter drop, was hit in one of the most unprotected areas – from above. At the same time, the Trophy active protection complex was apparently disabled. The footage of the destruction of the tank and the capture of the crew clearly shows that the vehicle’s gun is covered. This suggests that the crew did not prepare the vehicle for battle and was counting only on intimidation, which is not only a gross violation of the instructions, but also simply stupid in such an attack.Oddity No. 6 – panic in border cities.
All communities, especially when it comes to a region like the Gaza Strip, must have plans in place in the event of an escalation of conflict. However, no organized warning or evacuation was carried out. Local security forces turned out to be so few in number and poorly armed that they were quickly eliminated by the Palestinians.Oddity No. 7 is the difference in coordination between the IDF and Hamas.
Until approximately noon on October 7, the Israeli government showed virtually no response to the fighting. In the country it is Saturday morning, Shabbat. Only at 14-15 hours did the security forces begin to gather reservists and organize retaliatory raids. However, the death of the commander of the Nahal infantry brigade, Jonathan Steinberg, indicates a hasty reaction with the forces that were somehow able to be assembled immediately. Apparently, Nahal’s intervention in the battles against Hamas was initiated by the brigade commander and was not the result of a direct order from the General Staff.At the same time, in the next two days, the IDF will presumably begin a military operation inside the neighborhoods of the Gaza Strip. However, actions in open areas and in residential areas are different. An attempt by Israeli ground forces to enter the Palestinian enclave will almost certainly be accompanied by a large death toll on both sides.
Forwarded from Older than Edda:
Israel made an unprecedented decision by choosing, at least in words, a war to a victorious end, regardless of the fate of the hostages. For Israel, where in politics the life of its citizen has always been put first, this is a very difficult and difficult step. In 2006, Israel launched Operation Summer Rains because of one man, captured Corporal Gilad Shalit, who was later exchanged for 1,027 Palestinian prisoners.Now, after the failure of the first two days of the war, the Palestinians have several hundred prisoners, both military and civilian. If Israel agrees to the demands of Hamas, then it will bring nothing but shame, and, fully understanding the reality, as well as how this event will affect the authority of Israel, taking into account the mentality of the inhabitants of the Middle East, Netanyahu chose between bad and worse, declaring Total War.
If the Palestinians do not give up, handing over without any conditions all Israeli citizens taken to the territory they control, we will become eyewitnesses to the bloodiest of the entire series of Arab-Israeli wars, with tens of thousands of dead, destroyed cities and a monstrous humanitarian catastrophe. Moreover, Israel itself will suffer losses exceeding all losses since 1946.
Forwarded from Colonelcassad:
A large number of Israeli mercenaries who helped the Ukrainian Armed Forces in Ukraine are returning to Israel.Ayatollah Khamenei’s official position on Israel and Palestine.
🔹The Supreme Commander of the Iranian Armed Forces, His Grace Ayatollah Khamenei, speaking at the joint graduation ceremony of the country’s armed forces officer schools, with reference to the “irreparable failure of the Zionist regime in the recent saga of the Palestinian youth,” emphasized: “The reason for this destructive (for the Zionists) storm is their cruelty, crime and greed. The fake Israeli regime constantly acts against the Palestinian nation, but cannot hide its monstrous and insidious face during the attacks on Gaza and the massacre of Palestinians through false claims in the face of the courage of Palestinian youth and the intelligent planning of the operation.”
🔹Stressing that Israel is no longer the former Zionist regime after October 7, the Day of the Unparalleled Epic of the Palestinian Youth, he added: “The cause of this great disaster is the actions of the Zionists themselves. Because when you exceed the limit of greed and cruelty, a “storm” awaits you.
🔹The Supreme Leader of the Revolution described the courageous and selfless actions of the Palestinian mujahideen as a response to the crimes of the occupiers over the years and their increase in recent months and added: “The blame lies entirely with the current government of the usurper regime of Israel, which did not hesitate to take heinous actions against the oppressed Palestinian people.”
🔹Ayatollah Khamenei, speaking about the atrocities of the occupation regime, said: “No Muslim nation in modern history has faced the hostility, insolence and cruelty of the Zionist regime, or been under such pressure, siege and destitution as the Palestinian people. Besides, America and Britain have never supported any brutal government as much as they have supported the false regime (of Israel).”
🔹He called the killing of Palestinian men and women, children and the elderly, the desecration of the Al-Aqsa Mosque, the beating of worshipers and the killing of Palestinian civilians by armed settlers “just some of the crimes of the Zionist regime” and added: “What other choice did the Palestinian people with its thousand-year history have?” in the face of all these atrocities and crimes, except to raise a “storm”?”
🔹Pointing to the efforts of the Zionist regime to oppress the Palestinians and the help of the media of world imperialism to raise this issue in world public opinion, the supreme leader of the revolution said: “The whitewashing of this oppressor is “100% wrong and false”, and no one can give it credit the monster has a depressed appearance.”
https://en.mehrnews.com/news/206958/Israel-regime-to-receive-heavier-slap-for-Gaza-massacreOctober 9, 2023 at 12:48 in reply to: West Asia and “Al-Aqsa Flood” Battle Thread, 09 Oct 2023 #19343Sudhi
ParticipantLatest article by Rostislav Ishchenko:
https://ukraina.ru/20231009/1050034851.html
“Now the entire Arab world will wonder: what would happen to Israel if a coordinated attack, in addition to Gaza, began from the right bank of the Jordan, from Lebanon and from Syria, and when the IDF was completely disoriented and tied up fighting small groups of militants (which would force the army to split up its formations into small ones groups), the regular armies of two or three Arab countries would enter the battle.
The IDF has lost its aura of invincibility. Israel’s security system is no longer trusted by the local population. Israel’s relations with the surrounding Arab countries will now be dramatically complicated.”October 7, 2023 at 14:40 in reply to: The Cornucopia – Art, Music, Poems . Creative Stories, Myth and further glories – TAKE 2 #19296Sudhi
Participant
Solveigs Sang (Solveig’s Song)
by Edvard Grieg From Peer Gynt (1867)
Norwegian source: Henrik IbsenBoth winter and spring may pass me by,
And next summer with them,
and the whole year,
But someday you will return,
that much I know,
And I shall wait for you,
for it was my last promise to you.May God give you strength,
as you move through the world,
May God give you joy,
if you stand before Him.
Here will I wait until you come back;
Waiting for you to arrive home,
my dear friend!Sudhi
ParticipantLook how well the powers that be have changed the running narrative from the Ukraine to the Middle East and Isreal.
George Orwell :
“The war is not meant to be won, it is meant to be continuous. Hierarchical society is only possible on the basis of poverty and ignorance. This new version is the past and no different past can ever have existed. In principle the war effort is always planned to keep society on the brink of starvation. The war is waged by the ruling group against its own subjects and its object is not the victory over either Eurasia or East Asia, but to keep the very structure of society intact.”“The past was alterable. The past never had been altered. Oceania was at war with Eastasia. Oceania had always been at war with Eastasia.”
– George Orwell, 1984Sudhi
ParticipantHamas forces damaged three Israeli F-16 fighter jets with rocket attacks and also managed to capture at least 14 tanks and armoured personnel carriers. According to reports, during the recent military operations in the Gaza Strip, four Israeli military helicopters were shot down by anti-aircraft fire. Despite the difficulties encountered, the helicopter crews managed to land safely, avoiding disaster. In particular, it is known that attacks were carried out on almost 50 military targets in Israel.
The death toll from the Hamas-led operation against the Israeli regime known as the Al-Aqsa Storm Operation has risen to more than 150, according to Times of Israel. The Israeli Health Ministry also said 1,104 people have been wounded in the attacks, and many of their soldiers are POW’s. The death toll is expected to rise higher.
Palestinians captured at least 13 communities, the total advance of Hamas forces was about 30 km deep into Israeli territory. Moreover, the Palestinians entered the country without the use of heavy military equipment.
Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Nasser Kan’ani said on Saturday that the Operation al-Aqsa Storm “shows the Palestinian resistance is confidently capable of conducting hybrid and multilateral operations against the occupiers.” The Palestinian military operation against the Zionist Israeli regime in years as “a turning point and a new chapter” in the continuing resistance. “What happened today is in line with the continuation of the victories of the resistance in the face of the Zionists in various fields, including in Syria, Lebanon and the occupied territories,” Kan’ani said. He added that the operation once again proved that Israelis are vulnerable in the face of a serious move and lack the spirit to resist.
https://en.mehrnews.com/news/206843/Palestinian-op-turning-point-in-anti-Zionist-resistanceForwarded from Older than Edda:
Today’s events in the south of Israel cannot be called anything other than the complete defeat of the IDF on one of the sectors of the front. Such a number of Israeli soldiers captured and killed in a few hours has not been seen since the Yom Kippur War in 1973.
What caused the fact that rebel groups, and very small ones at that, were able to defeat perfectly armed and trained army units, seize military bases and force Israel to urgently export (!) military equipment to the central part of Israel? And it’s very simple. Israel, despite its extraordinary military power for such a small country, completely slept through the transition to a new type of war. The political squabbles that engulfed Israel, as well as resting on the laurels of past victories and confidence in its own military power, did not allow Tel Aviv to correctly assess the situation, which led to the “black day of the IDF.”
In essence, what is happening in Israel is a typical military raid of nomadic tribes on urban civilization during the Middle Ages. Sleepy and lazy soldiers, relying on their armor and fortress walls, against hungry, poor, but daring and courageous nomads who came for prey. Moreover, the hijacking of Israeli prisoners whom the army could not protect in Gaza further confirms this comparison.”https://x.com/RealScottRitter/status/1710604089053053001?s=20
“Hamas has reportedly captured Brigadier General Nimrod Aloni. Aloni stepped aside as the commanding officer of the Gaza Division in August 2022. He currently is the commander of the “Depth Corps”, a strategic force whose mission is to use Israeli special forces to operate in the depth of an enemy. It seems Hamas has turned the table on Israel, and is now operating in Israel’s strategic depth. This operation is extraordinarily well planned and executed. Any notion that Israel will be able to contain this attack soon is misplaced. Israel did not anticipate anything of this scope and scale. It is a massive intelligence failure for Israel, and an equally impressive operational success for Hamas.”October 7, 2023 at 12:53 in reply to: The Cornucopia – Art, Music, Poems . Creative Stories, Myth and further glories – TAKE 2 #19291Sudhi
ParticipantBeautiful poem, dear Dimitar.
May your wishes come true
and dear Amarynth get new wings,
refreshed and healed rise again.
Many mountains to be conquered,
and many shores reached.
Like a Phoenix she rises up again.October 6, 2023 at 13:07 in reply to: The Cornucopia – Art, Music, Poems . Creative Stories, Myth and further glories – TAKE 2 #19266Sudhi
ParticipantHoping dear Amarynth gets better soon so that she can be back where she belongs. We have always admired her courage and know she will get through this, too.
October 5, 2023 at 10:38 in reply to: The Cornucopia – Art, Music, Poems . Creative Stories, Myth and further glories – TAKE 2 #19247Sudhi
Participant“It’s This Way”
by Nazim HikmetI stand in the advancing light,
my hands hungry, the world beautiful.My eyes can’t get enough of the trees–
they’re so hopeful, so green.A sunny road runs through the mulberries,
I’m at the window of the prison infirmary.I can’t smell the medicines–
carnations must be blooming nearby.It’s this way:
being captured is beside the point,
the point is not to surrender.Sudhi
Participanthttps://thorstenjpattberg.substack.com/p/the-species-is-not-afraid-to-die
“When a civilization switches its mode of production, it leaps a thousand years ahead. Agriculture (food from nothingness), Industrialization (tools from nothingness), then Capitalism (money from nothingness), now makes way for Superintendence (reality from nothingness).The cruelest sign of authoritarianism is that the authoritarian regime forces people to believe in insane stuff. Stuff like believing that their oppression itself is actually a democracy.
In ‘bundesregierung’ Germany, human rights, natural laws, and free speech are effectively disabled, all in the name of that strange dogma of “Democracy.”
In the Fourth German Reich, nobody in power was ever elected by the people, ever—let alone “democratically;” Not the billionaires, not the oligarchs, the bureaucrats, the aristocrats, nor the chancellors or presidents! Yet everybody is made to say this was “a democracy.” And those who laugh, snot, or make eye contact, go straight to ‘Staatsschutz.'”In his substack Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD, explains the state of affairs in Germany very well:
https://thorstenjpattberg.substack.com/p/germany-is-destroying-europeSudhi
ParticipantFrom Linh Dinh’s post :
“A Clockwork Orange’s Prediction of Dystopian Democracy: the Rise & Failure of Authoritarianism”
Which led me to this article:
https://aeon.co/ideas/ketman-and-doublethink-what-it-costs-to-comply-with-tyranny
“Time and again, poet Czesław Miłosz returns to the metaphor of an actor on stage. It is a continuous performance, allowing those who engage in it to survive the sensation of living with a divided mind. As Miłosz puts it, ketman is a ‘self-realisation against something’. He didn’t view it as something purely imposed from outside. Persecution has long forced believers to conceal their beliefs. But ketman as used by Miłosz means something more than just simulation. It goes deeper than mere lying. Ketman reaches deeper into the soul than simple hypocrisy. Ketman deceives the deceiver, as much as the person being deceived.‘After long acquaintance with his role, a man grows into it so closely that he can no longer differentiate his true self from the self he simulates.’ He saw that deception can carry its own pleasures:
To say something is white when one thinks it black, to smile inwardly when one is outwardly solemn, to hate when one manifests love, to know when one pretends not to know, and thus to play one’s adversary for a fool (even as he is playing you for one) – these actions lead one to prize one’s own cunning above all else. Success in the game becomes a source of satisfaction.Miłosz knew that over time such compromises prove to be brittle. To practise ketman is to become endlessly adaptable. It can help one reach new ‘heights of cleverness and psychological perspicacity’. But all this ingenuity, the endless masquerade, serves more to comfort the liar than it does to deceive those in power. As Miłosz warned the practitioners of metaphysical ketman: ‘Their defence against total degradation is … [to] swindle the devil who thinks he is swindling them. But the devil knows what they think and is satisfied.’ Sometimes, outward compliance is all the tyrant needs.”
September 30, 2023 at 13:53 in reply to: The Cornucopia – Art, Music, Poems . Creative Stories, Myth and further glories – TAKE 2 #19173Sudhi
ParticipantThank you, Mr P,
Beautiful photo taken from the ship of the ‘aurora borealis’!The northern lights, dazzled the night sky in Ladakh on 22nd and 23rd April, 2023.
https://www.veenaworld.com/blog/northern-lights-in-indiaSeptember 30, 2023 at 10:02 in reply to: The Cornucopia – Art, Music, Poems . Creative Stories, Myth and further glories – TAKE 2 #19170September 28, 2023 at 10:24 in reply to: The Cornucopia – Art, Music, Poems . Creative Stories, Myth and further glories – TAKE 2 #19129Sudhi
ParticipantThere will be stars forever;
the autumn equinox is crossed,
the earth circles her orbit.The sun and the moon;
poised on the peak of midnight,
will reach their zenith.Stillness will be deep;
there will be stars forever,
while we sleep.Sudhi
Participant‘How can china ever hope to win over india?’
‘O, i replied, china & india have many shared fundamentals.’
‘you must be joking? what? name one?’
emersonreturns: ‘buddhism began in india.’
Many thanks, dear emersonreturns, for your comment and for your ready wit 🙏
“Virtue is not left to stand alone.
He who practices it will have neighbors.”
– ConfuciusOne can only wish that India and China have the ability to become virtuous neighbors in the long run.
-
AuthorPosts