The USSR can only be restored by reviving socialism
Featured Image: Ilya Repin’s painting “Barge Haulers on the Volga” (1870-73)
We know from other sources that Russia has been seeking for a deep representation of what they are. There is a new search for an identity that is expressed in a shorter slogan. The best way to explain it is to point to the Chinese slogan – socialism with Chinese characteristics or perhaps, a community of common destiny for mankind, or community with a shared future. We will soon see an article on the Russian search for a similar depiction of themselves.
It is not strange then that some in Russia seeks this in older communism. What is lost in that translation is that socialism is not static. It is not a destination but a journey. I for one cannot look forward to a revival of the Bolscheviks.
This is from Joti Brar.
The USSR can only be restored by reviving socialism
Today, the Russian presidential adviser Anton Kobyakov made a very remarkable statement. He noted that the procedure for dissolving the USSR in 1991 was violated, so the Soviet Union legally continues to exist.
Kobyakov said:
– If the Congress of People’s Deputies, also known as the Congress of Soviets, created the USSR in 1922, then it should have been dissolved by a decision of the Congress of these same deputies. And if the legal procedure was violated, then it turns out that the USSR legally exists, as constitutional law experts say.
We, communists, have long formulated this position. The USSR was created by the decision of the First All-Union Congress of Soviets, which brought together more than 2,000 delegates representing about 150 million people living not only in the RSFSR, Ukraine and Belarus, but also in Transcaucasia and Central Asia. Therefore, the decision to “dissolve the USSR”, made in Belovezhskaya Pushcha on December 8, 1991 by three not entirely sober subjects, is legal nonsense.
This is precisely why, having received powerful representation in the State Duma in the December 1995 elections, the CPRF achieved the denunciation of the Belovezh Accords in March 1996.
Of course, we welcome the fact that now a representative of the Russian executive power has supported the position of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation on the illegality of the destruction of the USSR.
But there is a very important point. In 1922, the USSR was created by representatives of the Soviet republics who decided to build a new, just society together – a socialist one. This was the great common cause that united hundreds of peoples in the area from the Baltic to Chukotka, from Taimyr to Pamir.
In order to bring these nations together again today, we must once again offer them the great idea of social justice. There are no other options. Therefore, if you really want the revival of the USSR, it is not enough to recognize its dissolution as legally null and void. We must begin with the restoration of socialism in Russia.
Translated from an original post by Yuri Afonin
Just thoughts… Kudos to all and especially Mr K! Of the evolution, the Bolshevik period did what was then necessary, and then failed as it became moribund. Yes, treason played a part, and greed…but it was more the result of systemic problems than the cause… The RF we have seen develop… Read more »
Thanks Mr P and btw i am a Ms K not a Mr 🙂 BTW What do you think of the American Grover Furr’s ideas that Stalin was largely lied about? I’m not one to dwell in the past too much as so much is no longer is provable, but… Read more »
Good question! Thanks! I will take some time to form a cogent opinion. I’ve read some letters between Stalin and FDR, I think people like Stalin have lives of great changes and several “faces”… and people lie by grasping only the one they want and sometimes just plain lie… But… Read more »
I feel that the events of the past 10 years or so especially have proven the Soviets or if you prefer the KPRF right in their views on the west and imperialism. The good will of the global majority when the SMO started, the industrial capacity to churn out weapons,… Read more »
Socialism by definition is a forward step for humanity, and the USSR already paid the price many times over to preserve it, it is inevitable that Russia will return to that path of developing socialism with Russian characteristics. Personally i don’t think it’s necessary or fair to demonise Stalin or… Read more »
K, well said. Just as a general point, a socialist system is any system that genuinely works for all of society. To focus on details or definitions distracts from the project. The world of the future will hopefully be comprised entirely of socialist systems, but all with their own characteristics.… Read more »
I don’t like coercion or inane polemic on ”isms. But I can so support this statement Steve: “A system should be anything its people want it to be.” I believe those people would end up somewhere on the scale of socialism, but not coerced. Venezuela is a very good example… Read more »
Yes Steve and it also occurs to me that along with demonising all forms of communism and socialism over the past century the west has managed to also demonise the English language. There is zero problem using any word with an “ism” political or not. Socialism is not a dirty… Read more »
Excellent K: And very well said. I love your allusion to music and mathematics in this context. I find that in my delving into Leftist and socialist thought and philosophy I am actually entering into a fascinating combination of intellect, poetry and music. When we encounter the inner force of… Read more »
bravo, K, you’ve brilliantly fixed a series of inexplicable decisions; all of which underscore primakov’s acuity. thank you!
Thank you em, i’m learning as i follow hunches on this discussion 🙂
I just found this article on the topic for anyone who is interested:
It is surprisingly objective and thorough even going into how Russia’s time in Syria fits in.
https://carnegieendowment.org/research/2019/06/the-primakov-not-gerasimov-doctrine-in-action?lang=en